|
Post by gwyn on May 30, 2023 5:42:04 GMT
But why slow the traffic in Film General even more by removing the top 10 polls from it? Your board is perfect the way it is. Be cautious of over-tweaking it. :) The original use of the film board (when there was only one) was reviews - watch a film, post a review. I have noticed that reviews now disappear off the front page quickly, so those interested in reviews were not being as well served. Meanwhile, I imagine some are not interested in top 10 german westerns of 1909, etc.I was/am trying to keep a happy medium for both audiences. Maybe Film Reviews could be the separate board while Film General is for polls and general chat? Yup, this. And if you post a new film thread or reply to an existent film thread, a user immediately posts fresh replies to one to two pages worth of top 10 threads, burying any fresh reply not belonging to them. It happens regularly, like clockwork. Your solve is perfect. Edit: Same goes for the POLL threads. They can be held to the rules you always had against board-spamming, or have their own board which is generous. The concept that they're rejecting both, and insisting they be allowed to hijack the main Film board, is anathema to me. I don't get zero willingness to meet others in the middle.
|
|
|
Post by Flying Monkeys on May 30, 2023 7:20:10 GMT
The original use of the film board (when there was only one) was reviews - watch a film, post a review. I have noticed that reviews now disappear off the front page quickly, so those interested in reviews were not being as well served. Meanwhile, I imagine some are not interested in top 10 german westerns of 1909, etc.I was/am trying to keep a happy medium for both audiences. Maybe Film Reviews could be the separate board while Film General is for polls and general chat? Yup, this. And if you post a new film thread or reply to an existent film thread, a user immediately posts fresh replies to one to two pages worth of top 10 threads, burying any fresh reply not belonging to them. It happens regularly, like clockwork. Your solve is perfect. Edit: Same goes for the POLL threads. They can be held to the rules you always had against board-spamming, or have their own board which is generous. The concept that they're rejecting both, and insisting they be allowed to hijack the main Film board, is anathema to me. I don't get zero willingness to meet others in the middle. Okay, feisty!
|
|
|
Post by gwyn on May 30, 2023 7:56:33 GMT
Yup, this. And if you post a new film thread or reply to an existent film thread, a user immediately posts fresh replies to one to two pages worth of top 10 threads, burying any fresh reply not belonging to them. It happens regularly, like clockwork. Your solve is perfect. Edit: Same goes for the POLL threads. They can be held to the rules you always had against board-spamming, or have their own board which is generous. The concept that they're rejecting both, and insisting they be allowed to hijack the main Film board, is anathema to me. I don't get zero willingness to meet others in the middle. Okay, feisty! Well it is the film board.
|
|