|
|
Post by Winter_King on Mar 11, 2024 17:12:09 GMT
Expressing concern for the victims in Gaza and Israel means attacking Israel. If he wasn't Jewish, he would be accused of being an anti semite. |
|
|
|
Post by SciFive on Mar 11, 2024 17:14:16 GMT
Israel has nearly half the Jews in the world to protect and this director accused Israel of hijacking the Holocaust.
Is he half the Jews in the world? No.
Has he contributed 7.3 million to the number of Jews in the world? No.
Israel has 7.3 million Jews and world Jewry is nearly (finally) reaching the number of Jews who existed prior to the Holocaust.
This number wouldn't be reachable without Israel. The Jewish state has grown from 650,000 in 1948 to 7.3 million Jews in 75 years. It's pretty much the most amazing Jewish population growth in the Jewish people's history.
It wouldn't be possible if Israel didn't defend herself and the Jews who live here.
|
|
|
|
Post by marsatax on Mar 12, 2024 2:03:18 GMT
Oh I see. Honestly Israel has no choice but to continue to occupy the West Bank otherwise we will see what’s happening in Gaza happen in the West Bank. Palestinians will put Islamists in power hell bent on war with Israel. We can argue about the past and who to blame, but that won’t change the present. It’s a shame we can’t just give the West Bank back to Jordan to control and keep sane. This whole situation is a cluster fuck. Send Canadian peacekeepers maybe?? The present is that Israel is wipping them out. He wasn’t talking about the West Bank. This is about the genocide of Gaza (or ethnic cleansing if it makes you feel better). The only Genocide in Gaza is what Hamas openly admits it wants to do to the Jews. Kind of funny how so-called leftists seem to have no problem with the Genocidal intentions of what is essentially a fascist organization. |
|
|
|
Post by marsatax on Mar 12, 2024 2:09:05 GMT
Israel is committing genocide and I don’t support the Hamas. You have no issues with the terrorism and murder the IDF commits against Palestinians for decades. You have a double standard and you support the genocide of Gaza. Shame on you.
No it is not. Leftists love to abuse language. First, Israel was "an apartheid state", even though it isn't. Then, it became a "colonialist regime", even though the vast majority of Israelis were born there. Now Israel is committing "Genocide", even though Israel has killed less than 2% of the population of Gaza, and many of the victims were Hamas fighters and terrorists. You have no issues with the terrorism and murder the IDF commits against Palestinians for decades. The Palestinians could end all the violence if they would agree to permanent peace with the Jewish state. They would rather continue the war. And leftists are fine with that. The leftist slogan "War is not the answer" goes out the window when it comes to the Palestinians. |
|
|
|
Post by marsatax on Mar 12, 2024 2:10:50 GMT
Israelis do get to play victim because they are fighting for their existence. Unlike the Jews in the holocaust, Hamas is still at war with Israel. There is no comparison but I’m sure that you know this. While I don’t support the Hamas, their popularity in the region is due to decades of Israel’s oppression of them. So, in a way, Israel created the conditions for 10/07 to happen. You can only oppress a people for so long before they retaliate. That explains why Israelis are not in the mood for any BS ceasefires. They can only take so much abuse before they decide to wipe out Hamas. |
|
|
|
Post by marsatax on Mar 12, 2024 2:12:28 GMT
Oh really? Please explain what parallels can be made between the industrial-scale attempt to exterminate every last Jew in Europe and a few thousand people dying as collateral damage in a war that their government started. Even allowing for the “exaggerating to make a point” factor you are lying. Shame, I thought better of you. Israel is not going to be that obvious. 29,000 people have been killed and many more are dying from famine and lack of resources. No they have stayed at the ghetto stage, without moving to the concentration camp stage. Israel has been a good balance to carry out their genocide without ruffling too many feathers. History will not be kind to Israel on this issue. You mean, the loony left will not be kind to Israel. But that is no surprise. |
|
|
|
Post by marsatax on Mar 12, 2024 2:14:42 GMT
No, this is your fantasy about what should happen to Jews again. Not mine. Yours. What you want to happened to Gazans and everyone that doesn’t agree with the genocide. Jewish or not. The only Genocide there is what Hamas wants to do to the Jews. |
|
|
|
Post by PaulsLaugh on Mar 12, 2024 6:25:11 GMT
Israel is committing genocide
Lie. About 1% of the Palestinians in Gaza have been killed, and a lot of them were Hamas fighters. This is not Genocide. I don’t support the Hamas.
Okay, let's test that. Hamas has openly promised to launch more October 7 massacres. What should Israel do to prevent that? Give the Palestinians a state? If they had one, what is to prevent them from using it as a base to launch more October 7 massacres? You have no issues with the terrorism and murder the IDF commits against Palestinians for decades.
For the most part, it is the Palestinians who engage in terrorism and murder against Israelis, not the other way around. It is not genocide but it is the first step in an ethnic cleansing campaign…. when this ends, settlers will flood into the region and grab up the prime real estate (they might even be doing it now or at least filing paperwork)…the innocent Palestinians not in Hamas will be forced into even more crowded ghettos with horrific living conditions. Israel will occupy the region indefinitely and those Palestinians will be living as second class citizens in the region….the region of Gaza will be an apartheid state. that is the only realistic scenario I see on how this turns out. of course, we have seen what happens when a non Muslim force tries to occupy a region with Muslim majority. It’s not pretty. And it will force Israel to use even more brutal means to maintain order. Israel is fighting a war attrition against the Hamas faction, which I do support, but the “collateral damage” they have produced in that war is unacceptable. I’m not saying Israel shouldn’t defend itself or wage war on the people responsible for the state-sponsored terrorist attack, however I’m criticizing how Israel is carrying out their war which is extremely lopsided without regard to innocent people too poor and uneducated to be held responsible for things beyond their control. If any here claims all Palestinian Muslims are Hamas or pro-Hamas, then explain your mind-reading techniques. We don’t kill people for what they might be thinking or because they are stuck believing in a hate production religion they didn’t invent nor have a choice in becoming. I also criticize the Israeli government’s handling of what has become a fiasco and disgrace to the Religion of Judaism. And Israeli high command may have a more sinister motive for not listening to reason from the USA and her other allies in conducting the war. This thread is supposed to be about a movie whose theme is the banality of evil. |
|
|
|
Post by jeffersoncody on Mar 12, 2024 6:45:29 GMT
It is not genocide but it is the first step in an ethnic cleansing campaign…. when this ends, settlers will flood into the region and grab up the prime real estate (they might even be doing it now or at least filing paperwork)…the innocent Palestinians not in Hamas will be forced into even more crowded ghettos with horrific living conditions. Israel will occupy the region indefinitely and those Palestinians will be living as second class citizens in the region….the region of Gaza will be an apartheid state. that is the only realistic scenario I see on how this turns out. of course, we have seen what happens when a non Muslim force tries to occupy a region with Muslim majority. It’s not pretty. And it will force Israel to use even more brutal means to maintain order. Israel is fighting a war attrition against the Hamas faction, which I do support, but the “collateral damage” they have produced in that war is unacceptable. I’m not saying Israel shouldn’t defend itself or wage war on the people responsible for the state-sponsored terrorist attack, however I’m criticizing how Israel is carrying out their war which is extremely lopsided without regard to innocent people too poor and uneducated to be held responsible for things beyond their control. If any here claims all Palestinian Muslims are Hamas or pro-Hamas, then explain your mind-reading techniques. We don’t kill people for what they might be thinking or because they are stuck believing in a hate production religion they didn’t invent nor have a choice in becoming. I also criticize the Israeli government’s handling of what has become a fiasco and disgrace to the Religion of Judaism. And Israeli high command may have a more sinister motive for not listening to reason from the USA and her other allies in conducting the war. This thread is supposed to be about a movie whose theme is the banality of evil. In my opinion, Israel should bomb Gaza mercilessly until the Hamas terrorists return the hostages and surrender. |
|
|
|
Post by PaulsLaugh on Mar 12, 2024 6:52:28 GMT
Israel is fighting a war attrition against the Hamas faction, which I do support, but the “collateral damage” they have produced in that war is unacceptable. I’m not saying Israel shouldn’t defend itself or wage war on the people responsible for the state-sponsored terrorist attack, however I’m criticizing how Israel is carrying out their war which is extremely lopsided without regard to innocent people too poor and uneducated to be held responsible for things beyond their control. If any here claims all Palestinian Muslims are Hamas or pro-Hamas, then explain your mind-reading techniques. We don’t kill people for what they might be thinking or because they are stuck believing in a hate production religion they didn’t invent nor have a choice in becoming. I also criticize the Israeli government’s handling of what has become a fiasco and disgrace to the Religion of Judaism. And Israeli high command may have a more sinister motive for not listening to reason from the USA and her other allies in conducting the war. This thread is supposed to be about a movie whose theme is the banality of evil. In my opinion, Israel should bomb Gaza mercilessly until the Hamas terrorists return the hostages and surrender.That’s barbarism. |
|
|
|
Post by jeffersoncody on Mar 12, 2024 6:56:52 GMT
No, it would be the right thing to do. Imagine if the allies had not crushed and destroyed Germany and Japan in WW2 you bloody fool and hypocrite. Hamas and their supporters in Palestine need to be destroyed at all costs. |
|
|
|
Post by PaulsLaugh on Mar 12, 2024 7:03:19 GMT
No, it would be the right thing to do. Imagine if the allies had not crushed and destroyed Germany and Japan in WW2 you bloody fool and hypocrite. Hamas and their supporters in Palestine need to be destroyed at all costs. This is hardly WWII and the Axis powers. Hamas needs to identified and destroyed. Again, we don’t do the barbaric “kill them all and let God take his own” bullshit anymore. Gaza is not Nazi Germany and the Jewish people worldwide, and the memory of Holocaust victims, do not deserve what is being done in their name. |
|
|
|
Post by jeffersoncody on Mar 12, 2024 7:30:25 GMT
No, it would be the right thing to do. Imagine if the allies had not crushed and destroyed Germany and Japan in WW2 you bloody fool and hypocrite. Hamas and their supporters in Palestine need to be destroyed at all costs. This is hardly WWII and the Axis powers. Hamas needs to identified and destroyed. Again, we don’t do the barbaric “kill them all and let God take his own” bullshit anymore. Gaza is not Nazi Germany and the Jewish people worldwide, and the memory of Holocaust victims, do not deserve what is being done in their name. You are a fucking hypocrite PaulsLaugh. W hy is it okay for Putin to bomb Ukraine? |
|
|
|
Post by PaulsLaugh on Mar 12, 2024 7:41:23 GMT
This is hardly WWII and the Axis powers. Hamas needs to identified and destroyed. Again, we don’t do the barbaric “kill them all and let God take his own” bullshit anymore. Gaza is not Nazi Germany and the Jewish people worldwide, and the memory of Holocaust victims, do not deserve what is being done in their name. You are a fucking hypocrite PaulsLaugh. W hy is it okay for Putin to bomb Ukraine? There is a third way, sometimes fourth and fifth ways, to think about things, just as there are many options of taking care of Hamas other continuing to kill humans caught in the middle of two extreme one-dimensional forces. You are condemning me for being pro-Hamas when I clearly stated I am not. Why can’t you accept I don’t share your opinion and that does mean I’m siding with the bad guys. |
|
|
|
Post by TheGoodMan19 on Mar 12, 2024 7:52:57 GMT
Six whole pages
One post about the movie
|
|
